There’s a kind of magic in the quiet rituals of a special gathering, the way the light filters through the curtains, the clink of teacups, the soft hum of conversation, and the little bites that say more than words ever could. Tea sandwiches, especially the delicate ones made with care, feel like an invitation to slow down. They remind me of afternoons that aren’t rushed, of celebrations that are more about connection than perfection.
That’s exactly the feeling I wanted to capture with this shrimp salad sandwich spread. It’s not fancy in the traditional sense, but it carries a certain grace. Just a few simple ingredients—cream cheese, yogurt, canned baby shrimp—and suddenly, you’ve created something that feels worthy of your grandmother’s china or a gathering with dear friends around the table.
I first made this while planning a springtime brunch, trying to find something light, lovely, and versatile enough to use in multiple ways. What surprised me most was how beautifully it fit into so many moments—tucked between slices of soft white bread, folded into mini croissants, or dolloped onto cucumber rounds. Wherever it lands, it feels like a little gift—subtle, elegant, and made with intention.
What stays with me most is how something so modest can still feel so meaningful. You don’t need a big budget or hours in the kitchen to create a sense of care and comfort. This recipe has become one I turn to again and again—not just because it’s easy, but because it makes people feel special. And in the end, that’s what really matters.
As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases, as well as commission via other affiliate links in this post. This is at no extra cost to you! Read the full disclosure here.
Simple, Thoughtful, and Crowd-Loved—Here’s Why
- Light but luscious: The combo of cream cheese and yogurt is creamy without being heavy.
- Fresh and herby: Dill and pickle juice brighten up the flavor and complement the shrimp beautifully.
- Make-ahead magic: Mix it up the day before and store in the fridge until party time. In fact it needs the extra time to meld the flavors perfectly.
- Budget-conscious: A little goes a long way—especially when served as tea sandwiches or appetizers.
Creamy Shrimp Salad Sandwich Spread
Equipment
- Mixing Bowl
- Hand Mixer
- Spatula or Spoon
- Measuring Spoons and cup
- Cutting Board and Knife
Ingredients
- 4 oz cream cheese softened
- 1/2 cup plain yogurt Greek or regular
- 1 tsp pickle juice
- 1/2 tsp Dijon mustard
- 1/2 tsp garlic powder
- 1/2 tsp onion powder
- 1/4 tsp celery seed or 2 tbsp finely diced celery
- 1/2 cup baby shrimp cooked, peeled, roughly chopped
- 1 tbsp fresh dill or 1 tsp dried
- 1 tbsp chopped chives or green onions optional
- Salt and pepper to taste
Instructions
- In a mixing bowl, whip the cream cheese until smooth.
- Add yogurt, pickle juice, mustard, garlic and onion powder, and celery. Mix until fully combined.
- Gently fold in shrimp, dill, and herbs.
- Taste and adjust seasoning. Chill for at least 30 minutes to 1 hour before serving. Ideally make the day before and let chill overnight.
Notes
Serving Ideas for Special Occasions
- Tea Sandwiches
Spread onto crustless white bread and cut into triangles or squares. Garnish with a tiny sprig of dill for presentation points.
- Mini Croissant Sandwiches
Scoop into mini croissants with a slice of cucumber or butter lettuce. These are perfect for brunches and showers.
- Low-Carb Cucumber Bites
Spoon onto thick cucumber rounds for a refreshing, gluten-free option. Bonus points if you top them with a sprinkle of paprika.
- Dip for Crackers or Vegetables
Serve chilled in a pretty dish with crackers, pita chips, or vegetables. Add a sprinkle of fresh herbs on top just before guests arrive.
- Pinwheel Appetizer
Spread the mixture onto a large flour tortilla, roll it up tightly, then chill and slice into bite-sized pinwheels for an easy, elegant appetizer.
Budget-Friendly Hosting Tips
• Use frozen baby shrimp instead of fresh.
Frozen cooked shrimp are a fraction of the cost of fresh and often come pre-peeled, which saves time too. Just thaw them in a colander under cool water, pat dry with a paper towel to avoid watering down your dip and chop them up if they’re on the larger side. You get all the flavor, texture, and elegance—without the high price tag.
• Make a double batch and split it between dip and sandwich spread duties.
One recipe, two uses. Serve part of it in a pretty bowl with crackers for guests to nibble and tuck the rest into delicate tea sandwiches or croissants. It’s an easy way to stretch the same ingredients across your menu while still offering variety.
• Repurpose leftovers into new dishes.
Don’t let a spoonful go to waste! This spread makes a surprisingly tasty toast topper—just smear it onto a slice of sourdough or a bagel and pop it under the broiler until bubbly and golden. You can also spoon it into halved cherry tomatoes or small hollowed-out cucumbers for an elegant appetizer twist. Feeling extra thrifty? Stir leftovers into cooked pasta with a splash of reserved pasta water or broth for a quick and creamy pasta.
Creative Ways to Use Leftovers
- Shrimp Melt Toasts
Spread onto sliced bread or halved English muffins, top with a sprinkle of shredded cheese (mozzarella, cheddar, or Swiss all work), and broil until bubbly and golden. Serve with a simple side salad for a light lunch.
- Creamy Shrimp Pasta
Stir the leftover spread into hot cooked pasta with a splash of reserved pasta water or broth. Add steamed veggies like peas, spinach, or zucchini for a quick, creamy seafood pasta dish that tastes like it took way more effort.
- Stuffed Cherry Tomatoes or Cucumber Cups
Hollow out cherry tomatoes or thick cucumber slices and pipe or spoon in the shrimp spread. These are perfect for low-carb snacking or as a pretty addition to a lunch tray or appetizer platter.
- Shrimp Deviled Eggs
Mix a small spoonful of the shrimp spread into the yolk mixture when making deviled eggs. It adds a savory seafood twist and stretches a small amount of filling across more eggs.
- Morning Bagel Spread
Use it as a savory schmear for toasted bagels or even English muffins. It’s a fresh and satisfying breakfast option, especially with a few thin cucumber slices or baby greens layered on top.
- Warm Dip Twist
Add a sprinkle of shredded cheese and bake the leftover spread in a small dish at 350°F for about 15 minutes. Serve warm with crostini or crackers for a last-minute appetizer.
- Shrimp Salad Lettuce Wraps
Spoon the chilled spread into crisp romaine or butter lettuce leaves for a low-carb lunch option. Top with extra herbs, diced cucumber, or even a sprinkle of crushed crackers for texture.
Final Thoughts
Some of the most meaningful meals I’ve shared weren’t elaborate or expensive. They were simple, homemade, and served with the kind of quiet love that fills a room more than any centerpiece ever could.
That’s the heart behind this creamy shrimp spread. It’s not flashy—but there’s something about it that feels special. Maybe it’s the way it turns everyday ingredients into something comforting and elegant. Maybe it’s how it invites people to slow down and savor. Or maybe it’s just the joy of offering something made with care.
When I make this, I’m not just filling a plate—I’m creating a moment. A moment where someone feels seen, celebrated, and nourished. And honestly, that’s what makes any gathering memorable—not the cost, but the feeling.
Discover more from Budgeting on a Dime
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.
