It always starts the same way. I’m halfway through baking a batch of pumpkin muffins, measuring out the purée, when I realize—again—I’ve got half a can left. Not enough for another full recipe, but too much to throw away without a little guilt creeping in.
So into the fridge it goes… where it sits until I forget about it. Sound familiar?
Over the years, I’ve gotten tired of that cycle. And we both know—ingredients aren’t cheap these days. Wasting even a few spoonfuls feels like tossing out potential. That’s when I started looking at leftovers differently—not as scraps, but as building blocks for something new.
One of the easiest—and most comforting—ways to use up that extra pumpkin is pie. Whether it’s a quick no-bake version, a crustless twist, or a cozy classic made with whatever’s already in the pantry, pumpkin pie is one of those flexible desserts that feels like a treat without asking for much in return.
I’ve pulled together some simple ways to turn leftover purée into pie, along with a few ideas for when you’ve only got a spoonful or two to spare. Whether you’re planning ahead or simply making the most of what’s already open, you’ll find a sweet, budget-friendly option that fits right in.
✨ Transparency Matters
Some links in this post may be affiliate links. That means I may earn a small commission — including as an Amazon Associate — at no extra cost to you.
Before you can turn those leftovers into pie (or anything else), it’s important to know how long pumpkin purée actually keeps. Whether it came from a can or was homemade from a fresh pumpkin, proper storage makes all the difference between something usable and something that ends up in the trash.
Refrigerator Storage
Once opened, canned pumpkin should be transferred to an airtight container and stored in the fridge. It’ll stay fresh for about 5 to 7 days—just long enough to work it into your weekly meal plan.
Tip: Write the date on the container with a bit of painter’s tape or a dry-erase marker so it doesn’t get forgotten behind the salsa. Keep items that need to be used first in a separate quick-grab tup at the front of the fridge.
Freezer Storage
If you’re not planning to use it right away, pumpkin purée freezes beautifully. Spoon it into silicone ice cube trays or portion it out by the half-cup or cup in freezer bags or containers. It’ll keep for up to 3 months without losing quality.
Let it thaw overnight in the fridge or defrost it gently in the microwave when you’re ready to bake.
Frozen purée might release a bit of liquid when thawed—just stir or blot it before using in pies or batters.
Homemade Pumpkin Purée
If you made your purée from scratch, the same rules apply: refrigerate for up to a week, freeze for longer. Just make sure it’s fully cooled before storing.
A rich and nutty twist on the classic, this pumpkin pie features a golden pecan topping that adds the perfect crunchy contrast to its smooth, spiced filling. It’s a cozy, crowd-pleasing favorite that feels elegant enough for a holiday table but simple enough for a casual fall weekend. If you’re looking for pumpkin desserts that feel a little elevated without extra effort, this one delivers. Serve it with whipped cream or vanilla ice cream for a slice that’s as beautiful as it is delicious.
What makes this recipe unique? The pecan topping adds texture and depth without needing a separate pecan pie.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use homemade pie crust and omit the pecan topping if needed.
How long does this recipe take? About 1 hour
What is the experience level? Beginner to Intermediate
This velvety pumpkin pie skips the evaporated milk in favor of sweetened condensed, delivering extra creaminess with fewer ingredients and no compromise on flavor. It’s rich, smooth, and perfectly spiced—making it one of those pumpkin desserts you’ll want to make on repeat all season long. With its pantry-friendly ingredients and effortless prep, it’s a reliable go-to whether you’re hosting Thanksgiving or just craving something sweet and seasonal.
What makes this recipe unique? Sweetened condensed milk creates a smoother, silkier pie with less sugar needed.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Store-brand condensed milk works great; use a graham crust if on hand.
How long does this recipe take? About 1 hour (including bake time)
A creamy, classic pumpkin pie filling meets a buttery graham cracker crust in this cozy twist on tradition. It’s the best of both worlds—silky, spiced custard layered over a sweet, crumbly base that adds texture and depth. Perfect for when you want something familiar but with a little extra charm, this recipe stands out among easy pumpkin desserts. Serve it chilled or with a dollop of whipped cream for a crowd-pleasing finish to any fall meal. It’s simple to make, easy to love, and even better the next day.
What makes this recipe unique? Skips traditional pastry crust for a graham cracker shell.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use store-brand graham crackers or DIY crust with cereal crumbs.
This one-bowl recipe is ideal for busy bakers, combining canned pumpkin and sweetened condensed milk into one simple, fuss-free pie. With warm spices and a soft, custardy texture, it’s the kind of nostalgic dessert that brings comfort with every bite. Beginner-friendly and made with pantry staples, it’s a must-try for anyone craving classic pumpkin desserts without the mess or stress. Just mix, pour, bake—and enjoy a slice of fall simplicity.
What makes this recipe unique? It’s a low-mess, one-bowl option with fewer measuring cups and dishes.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Pre-made crust or biscuit base can keep things cheap and easy.
How long does this recipe take? About 50–55 minutes
If you’re out of canned milk or just prefer a simpler ingredient list, this version is a great go-to. Made with regular milk, it delivers that classic pumpkin pie flavor you love—just with a lighter, silkier texture. It’s perfect for those who want a traditional pie without the extra fuss, and it proves that pumpkin desserts don’t need a long ingredient list to be delicious. Easy, familiar, and endlessly comforting, it’s a cozy addition to any fall baking lineup.
What makes this recipe unique? Skips evaporated milk and keeps ingredients super accessible.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? About 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use whole, 2%, or even dairy-free milk alternatives.
How long does this recipe take? About 1 hour
What is the experience level? Beginner
Is this a good option for a gathering? Yes — especially helpful if someone needs to avoid processed dairy.
This no-bake pumpkin cream pie is ultra-light, airy, and full of fall flavor. The whipped topping melts on your tongue, while the graham cracker crust adds just the right amount of sweet crunch. It’s the kind of dessert that feels indulgent but takes hardly any effort—no oven required. Whether you’re short on time or just want something cool and creamy, this is one of those pumpkin desserts that always disappears fast at fall gatherings.
What makes this recipe unique? A mousse-like pumpkin filling that doesn’t require baking.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? ¾ cup to 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use store-brand whipped topping and crushed cereal instead of graham crackers for the crust.
How long does this recipe take? About 15 minutes to prep, plus chill time
This layered pie combines pumpkin, cheesecake, and toasted pecans for a triple-threat dessert that tastes like three fall favorites in one slice. With creamy pumpkin custard, a tangy cheesecake layer, and a buttery pecan topping, it’s the ultimate blend of textures—smooth, crunchy, and perfectly spiced. If you’re looking for pumpkin desserts that feel a little extra without being complicated, this one delivers big flavor and showstopping appeal.
What makes this recipe unique? It’s a hybrid dessert — part cheesecake, part pie, part pecan topping.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Sub crushed cookies or oats for pecans in the topping to save on nuts.
How long does this recipe take? About 1 hour, plus chill time
What is the experience level? Intermediate
Quick Callouts
✴️Great for holiday dessert tables
✴️Easy to tweak for allergies (pecan-free topping)
A fall twist on a French classic, these pumpkin pie cream puffs are filled with silky pumpkin-spiced pastry cream and finished with a delicate dusting of powdered sugar. Light, airy, and bursting with cozy flavor, they’re an elegant way to serve pumpkin desserts that still feels fun and festive. Perfect for autumn gatherings, dessert tables, or a bake-that-impresses moment—without being overly complicated. They look bakery-worthy but come together with simple ingredients and a little patience.
What makes this recipe unique? Combines pâte à choux with pumpkin for an upscale dessert.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? ½ cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Skip fancy piping bags — a zip-top bag works for filling.
How long does this recipe take? Around 90 minutes from start to finish
What is the experience level? Intermediate to Advanced
These soft sandwich cookies are filled with luscious cream cheese frosting and packed with warm pumpkin spice flavor. Like a hand-held slice of pumpkin cake with a creamy center, they’re the definition of fall comfort food. Perfect for lunchboxes, potlucks, or cozy weekend baking, they’re one of those pumpkin desserts that feels nostalgic, satisfying, and just indulgent enough. You’ll want to make a double batch—they disappear fast!
What makes this recipe unique? It’s basically cake, frosting, and nostalgia all in one bite.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? ¾ to 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? DIY your frosting or use vanilla yogurt as a lighter filling.
How long does this recipe take? 35–40 minutes
What is the experience level? Beginner to Intermediate
This hands-off pumpkin pie pudding is slow-cooked to silky perfection, delivering all the cozy flavor of traditional pumpkin pie—without ever turning on the oven. It’s rich, spiced, and spoonably soft, making it perfect for busy holidays, small kitchens, or when you just want an easy set-it-and-forget-it treat. As far as pumpkin desserts go, this one checks all the boxes: comforting, low-effort, and incredibly satisfying. Serve it warm with a dollop of whipped cream or chilled straight from the fridge—it’s delicious either way.
What makes this recipe unique? It’s made entirely in a slow cooker with a custardy, scoopable texture.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use homemade pumpkin pie spice and store-brand condensed milk.
How long does this recipe take? About 2.5–3 hours on low
This indulgent no-bake pie pairs pumpkin and salted caramel in a buttery graham cracker crust for a rich, luxurious twist on the classic. The creamy, chilled filling is perfectly balanced with warm spices and a hint of salt, making it a standout among pumpkin desserts. With zero oven time and maximum flavor, it’s an ideal make-ahead treat for fall gatherings, Friendsgiving, or any night you’re craving something cozy and a little bit fancy.
What makes this recipe unique? The salted caramel topping adds a sophisticated sweet-salty finish.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? ¾ to 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use homemade caramel or a drizzle of maple syrup instead.
How long does this recipe take? About 20 minutes prep + chill time
What is the experience level? Beginner to Intermediate
This elevated pumpkin pie gets a grown-up twist with a splash of bourbon, adding just the right amount of warmth and depth to every bite. The rich, spiced filling stays true to the comforting classic, but the subtle kick gives it a little extra personality—perfect for holiday tables or fall dinner parties. If you’re craving pumpkin desserts with a sophisticated edge, this one delivers all the flavor with a modern flair. Serve it with whipped cream or a drizzle of caramel for an unforgettable finish.
What makes this recipe unique? Bourbon brings out the spice and enhances the pumpkin flavor.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Skip the bourbon or sub with vanilla if needed.
How long does this recipe take? About 1 hour
What is the experience level? Intermediate
Is this a good option for a gathering? Yes — perfect for adults-only events or Friendsgiving.
This pumpkin pie crumble skips the crust and goes straight for the good stuff: a silky, spiced pumpkin filling topped with a buttery brown sugar streusel. It’s warm, rustic, and packed with fall flavor—perfect for those days when you’re craving pie but don’t feel like making a crust from scratch. Easy to prep and even easier to love, this is one of those pumpkin desserts that brings comfort without complication. Serve it with a scoop of vanilla ice cream for extra coziness. Leftovers (if there are any) reheat beautifully for next-day snacking.
What makes this recipe unique? Crust-free and topped with a crisp, buttery crumble instead.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use oats or granola in the topping to stretch ingredients.
How long does this recipe take? About 45–50 minutes
This gluten-free pumpkin pie delivers all the classic flavor and texture you love—without the wheat. A buttery almond flour crust holds a smooth, spiced filling that’s every bit as creamy and comforting as the original. Whether you’re baking for dietary needs or just exploring new pumpkin desserts, this version is simple, satisfying, and perfect for sharing. No one will miss the traditional crust once they’ve had a slice of this cozy fall favorite.
What makes this recipe unique? It’s a gluten-free version that doesn’t feel like a compromise.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Sub coconut milk for cream and use store-brand almond flour.
How long does this recipe take? About 1 hour (including bake time)
What is the experience level? Intermediate
Is this a good option for a gathering? Yes — especially if you need a dessert that’s allergy-conscious.
These pumpkin pie bars are naturally gluten-free, vegan, and free of the top 8 allergens, making them a go-to option for gatherings where dietary needs vary. With a creamy pumpkin filling and a soft, spiced crust, they offer all the cozy flavor of traditional pie in an easy-to-serve format. Perfect for potlucks, school events, or holiday tables, these bars prove that pumpkin desserts can be inclusive, delicious, and incredibly convenient.
What makes this recipe unique? It’s free of gluten, dairy, eggs, soy, and nuts — but still full of flavor.
How much leftover pumpkin puree do I need? 1 cup
Are there any budget-friendly ingredient swaps? Use homemade oat flour or a basic GF flour blend.
How long does this recipe take? About 45 minutes
What is the experience level? Beginner
Is this a good option for a gathering? Absolutely — the bar format makes them ideal for potlucks and parties.
Quick Callouts
✴️Vegan + allergy-friendly
✴️Uses full cup of pumpkin
✴️Great for school lunches or snacks
Final Thoughts: Pumpkin Pie with Leftover Pumpkin Puree
It always starts the same way: I open the fridge and spot that half-used can of pumpkin purée sitting on the shelf, daring me to do something with it. Toss it? Not a chance.
That’s how some of my favorite recipes have come to life—born from leftovers and a little creativity.
Whether it’s layering pumpkin into cream pies, folding it into whoopie pies, or blending it into a slow-cooker pudding, these recipes turn “just a little bit left” into something worth sharing.
You don’t need a full baking day or a mile-long ingredient list. Just a scoop of pumpkin, a bit of inspiration, and maybe a craving for something warm and spiced. These recipes make it easy to stretch what you already have into desserts that feel thoughtful, festive, and totally satisfying.
Which one will you make with your leftovers? Let me know—I’d love to see what you whip up!
